Friday, December 10, 2010

it's been exactly a year since i wrote this.




have i changed? i don't think so. but maybe that is in itself a problem.


A SEMESTER WITHOUT BARRIERS.

This past semester i've been part of a program called Soliya: Arab American Dialogues. check it out at www.soliya.net if ur interested. it's been an invigorating experience, mostly internally. But we can discuss that another time :)
our very first project for the class was to write a piece in which we described how we experience "conflict". our second major assignment was to make a video depicting the Israeli attacks on Gaza last year, we were given raw footage from AP, Al Jazeera and some other accredited news stations. That in itself was an intense experience. you can check out my video here if you would like:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GaII2e8RZLU
my classmate did something unique for the project. he had a former israeli
soldier give his narration of the attacks on gaza, and he had me give my narration. then he meshed our stories together to tell the same story. it was ridiculously powerful. unfortunately i am not at liberty to share that video, at least not yet.
our Final Project of the semester was to initiate a dialogue between
ourself and someone else who is part of the "other," other meaning belonging to a frame of mind that you have a conflict with, or disagree with substantively. the goal was to understand them. plain and simple. not to change their mind, not to stress your own points, but to listen and try really hard to understand them. id been struggling with this the entire semester. I kept thinking of the many situations i had been in, specifically protests where members of "the other" were yelling in my face, insulting and belittling the very cause we were calling attention to. many times i wanted to pull those people aside and really talk to them. i could never fathom what possessed them. the main focus of our class was the Israel Palestine conflict. .... so what did i choose? i decided to meet with the former idf soldier that had co-narrated the aforementioned video. The following is what I wrote after meeting with him. i couldn’t think of how to translate my thoughts into a paper, so I decided to write the “other” a letter:
Dear Other,
I’ve always wanted to understand you. I’ve always wanted to hear your words and have them make sense. I’ve always told myself that. And for the most part, I’ve always believed me. But the fact of the matter is that this positive “want” is not so. I’ve realized that now. Now that I have been honest enough with myself and faced my prejudices and biases; I don’t understand you.What is understanding you? I don’t feel as though this word is enough. If you take apart the word Understanding, you get two words. Under and Standing. Regardless of the etymology, it sounds like taking a step down. Standing under in order to see what you see, what the “other” sees. This is fine. I can hear you out. I can see where you are coming from.But I cannot place myself beneath you any further than I already am in current and
historical societal circumstance; and still remain standing.
I can flip my rational upside down and close my eyes, shaking my head left and right, I can “understand you.” Amidst my confusion. But when the fog clears, I still don’t get it.

Its like standing on opposites side of a glass pane, and you are speaking to me from underwater. I see your lips moving, I know it makes sense to you, you believe in what you are saying. Im trying to read your lips but bubbles keep emerging and I don’t hear your words. I try, I won’t walk away. But that is how I feel. I feel like we, Palestinians and Israelis stand like this, over and over through history and present day, facing each other, talking at and talking with, but are we really hearing?

I hear you. But you are muffled. The clarity of your words, is not backed by trust. I don’t trust you. The fact of the matter is that things are better for you than they are for me. My people that is. At the end of the day, you go home, you can pat yourself on the back for a job well done. You reached out. You made a new friend, took a step forward. But what do I bring back? I am not pessimistic, but change is not only in my hands. And reaching out is not enough for me, or my people, and more vastly, OUR people. It is not enough. We are all just going to keep on suffering. I feel the pain that you inflict, and you sit gritting your teeth, and firing missiles to preemptively deter “possible threats”.

I’m sorry. let me apologize, I am getting ahe
ad of myself and much too worked up.  

I am writing this because I want to listen to you, I want to understand you. I wish I could tell you how nervous you make me. I know the thoughts that run through my mind prior to our meeting are irrational, but I still think them. I am antsy because I think that whatever I say to you can and will be used against me, I feel like I have a lot more at risk in meeting with you than you do in meeting me. I don’t feel this apprehension with any sort of stranger, but with you, a member of the other, I do. You probably have a voice recorder on you, you are probably going to capture what I say then document it in some file so that next time I fly to Palestine, yes PALESTINE, I will be heckled beyond belief by the airport security in tel aviv.
That is what I am thinking. But I present to you a smile that encourages easy conversation, and you laugh at my jokes. And I feel fake.
And Then I stop. This has to be just as awkward for you as it is for me. So lets not make it awkward, lets make it genuine, two people meet…but wait. We aren’t just two people… well we are,.. but we aren’t, we are a specific two people. This aspect frustrates the hell out of me. Half my brain tells me to avoid talking politics, but the other half is screaming questions. I just want to know. And politics is what brought us together in the first place, isn’t it?
Part of me wants you to answer for all the negative experiences I have had with people of the “other.” I want to hold YOU accountable for them. Like the millions of times my people have been collectively punished, I want to single you out for the massacres of Deir Yassin, Sabra and Shatila, Jenin, the illegal
occupation, for choking then blowing up gaza, for killing my cousin, for destroying my grandfather, for torturing my family, I want to blame you for all of that. There is so much pain and so much hurt, ripping inside of me after years and years of having to defend my peoples existence, explaining to people that “no the ones killed were not militants, no they didn’t have any weapons, they were innocent” when they all believe Israel was defending itself and in its right. I want to blame you for the lies.
And then I feel tired. I look at you and I really don’t see anger, I don’t see rage and mass killing. And I just want to close my eyes. This is such a mess. A bloody confused backwards mess. Is it really this complicated?
You cannot even tell that this is what is going on within me. You only see my front, which I display well. I realize I really do have great composure, you have no clue. And I am just going to try and understand you. If something so raging and complex is going on within me as I sit across from you and smile pleasantly, maybe its possible that you are experiencing the same anguish.
You keep mentioning suicide bombings.
I realize now that the mention of suicide bombings triggers some sort of an off switch within me. I pay attention to this reaction of mine because It is necessary to be aware of it. Why does this phrase shut me down? I think its because i cannot equate the suicide bombings Palestinians have carried out against Israelis, with the amount of atrocities the Israelis have carried out against Palestinians.
But this is not about equality. is it? So I catch myself. Killing is wrong, right? And no matter where you stand you don’t deserve to die if you are unfortunately trapped in a huge political mess. So I must be fair. I am sorry, I am sorry for all the people that have died at the hands of this bloody conflict. I am sorry that your civilians were killed while they were having lunch at a nice restaurant, or dancing at a night club, or living in their homes. I am sorry. I bite my tongue and mentally slap myself for thinking silently, “at least your people have fancy restaurants and a livelihood to miss”. I am ashamed that I think these things, but im trying to be honest.
You tell me that you served in the idf, but only for intelligence services. You almost seem relieved that you served only for intelligence. The shiver that I see run through you as you say “I never served in the territories, no, no I never dealt with the civilians or the occupation first hand, thank god. Ive never had to do anything immoral.” what am I to make of your body language. What am I to make of that last statement. Ive never had to do anything immoral. Well that’s good. Thank you. I wonder if your relief is only because you are speaking to me. A Palestinian. If you were speaking to a fellow Israeli would you say something different?
I am being too harsh, ive seen soldiers like you in the west bank. Ones who ask nicely for our passports, who smile at the little children, ones who truly try to “make the best” out of their service. But as a wise man once said, a former idf soldier as well, an Israeli in the west bank of Palestine is like being white in south Africa during the apartheid. You don’t need any special recognition, your mere presence is enough to let those around know they are oppressed.
You tell me that you feel Israel needs to acknowledge the Palestinians, that both sides need to acknowledge each other. I respect that. I can see eye to eye with that statement. You talk about how you really want to study Arabic, you tell me that the people of Israel live somewhat brainwashed, well you don’t say it in those words, but you say that they live in constant fear, whether that fear is rational or not is a different story. But then again how can you rationalize a feeling…
You tell me that there are many arabs within Israel, palestnians, who live just as well as Israelis. That it is not uncommon to see a woman wearing a head scarf, in fact its very usual. You tell me that you hear people speaking Arabic regularly.
And here our narratives clash. You are painting for me this lovely picture, and I don’t believe it for one second. I have seen the ghettos where the arabs live. I have seen the lack of sewage systems, the disparity in the quality of life…equal?
Then you say that there is not as much integration as you would like, that you think arabs and jews should really talk to one another more…You tell me that you have lived your whole life in Israel, yet you have never been to the west bank. You ask me what its like there. Ask me? I tell you the village my family is from and instantly you know it. Why? Because of the check point located next to it. You have not seen how the Palestinians live under occupation, well my friend, that would definitely be a step to understanding, and since Palestinians from the west bank or gaza cannot get into Israel, I think you should take a road trip. But you won’t. Will you?
And I am miffed. How can two peoples live side by side, and not speak to one another. Oh I know how, apartheid, occupation, dehumanization of each other… You tell me that you imagine the arabs within Israel must deal with horrible identity crisis. I notice how you refrain from calling those arabs “Palestinians”. Its these little things that
You feel sorry for them. I understand from you that you are acknowledging the prejudice that goes on within Israel towards the Palestinians, the arabs. And I know that this should be seen as a kind gesture, an attempt for betterment. So thank you.
Im going to try, I decided, to step into your shoes for a moment, and I play back my thoughts. I cringe.
I cringe because I hear the anger in my own voice and the volatile emotions stirring in the nuances of every word I think.
And it makes me feel bad. I remember when I was talking with you, it is at these times, when I would say these words that you would nod. I don’t know if you were nodding in agreement, or perhaps you were simply… understanding?
And that leads me full circle. Agreement and understanding are not both necessary to each other. We do not owe each other anything but the chance to be understood.
We are two people. just two people. and our backgrounds are as they are, we cannot change the fact that our people live in turmoil with one another, we can either choose to work toward peace, or we can fit the line of history and continue fighting each other. I need to be able to hear you out without feeling threatened or traitorous to my people. because my “people” are not just MY people, we are all part of a bigger society, region, global community. We are all connected. As long as one of us is suffering, we will all suffer. The banality of evil. As Hanna Arendt pointed out, the greatest evils in our world are not carried out by sociopaths or fanatics, but by ordinary people, you and me, who accept the premises of our conflicts and take them as normal. Somewhere the chain must be broken. Or connected.
So Thank you “other” for our meeting has shed light on the responsibility the both of us have accepted. I have accepted this responsibility of learning to understand you. Face to face, person to person one life to another. This responsibility may just be our people’s biggest chance at peace. And I wont be the one to cheat them out of it.
Sincerely yours,
“the other other”

1 comment:

  1. * i did not intend for the font size changes that occur throughout the piece*

    ReplyDelete